
On 9 June 2026, Centre for Law and Religious Freedom at the Department of Roman Law at Jagiellonian University and the Religious Freedom Clinic at Harvard Law School intervened as a third party before the European Court of Human Rights in the case Pontificia, Real y Venerable Esclavitud del Santísimo Cristo de la Laguna and Diocese of San Cristóbal de la Laguna v. Spain (Application no. 7421/25). This constitutes our direct submission of written comments to the Strasbourg Court.
On 20 May 2026 the President of the Fifth Section has granted leave, under Rule 44 §3 of the Rules of Court to make written submissions to the Court on behalf of the Centre for Law and Religious Freedom at Jagiellonian University, and on behalf of the Religious Freedom Clinic at Harvard Law School. Our joint intervention does not include any comments on the facts or merits of the case, but addresses only the general principles applicable to the determination of the case.
The case concerns the refusal of a historic Catholic brotherhood (Pontificia, Real y Venerable Esclavitud del Santísimo Cristo de la Laguna), known mainly for its Holy Week processions, to admit a female applicant as a member and the subsequent finding by the Spanish Constitutional Court that this refusal violated constitutional equality guarantees.
Interveners submitted these comments to assist the Court in reaching a just and equitable result and in properly interpreting the Parties’ obligations set forth in the Convention. To that end, we offer a comparative view that highlights a common thread across Europe and the United States. Across Western legal systems, religious communities have long enjoyed autonomy over their internal affairs, especially in matters of membership. That consensus is relevant here, because how this Court resolves the question presented will have consequences for religious organisations throughout the Member States.
Our written comments submitted to the Strasbourg Court are available here.